OpEd: Quality in Education Must Mean More Than a Certificate

Opinion Editorial by Prof. Stéphane Narcis, the Honorary President and Honorary QA Auditor at QAHE.

Featured Image

Higher education students in a discussion.-- Photo: QAHE

When a student chooses a course, the decision is rarely about a certificate alone. It is about the hope of finding meaningful work, developing professional confidence, supporting a family, or pursuing further study. For that reason, the discussion about educational quality should begin not with an institution’s achievements, but with the promises it makes to its learners.

Can students understand what they are paying for? Will they receive the teaching and support they need? Will their qualification serve the purpose they have in mind?

These are the questions that should shape a meaningful conversation about quality in education.

For the Maldives, that conversation should recognise the role of the national quality assurance framework. The Maldives Qualifications Authority’s institutional audit guidelines already emphasise self-evaluation, external review, student engagement, and the development of a continuing quality culture. The underlying principle is important: quality assurance should support institutional improvement, not simply produce a favourable assessment.

The challenge for educators is to make that principle visible in the everyday experience of students.

Begin with clear information

An institution’s responsibility to its learners begins before enrolment.

Prospective students should be able to find clear information about entry requirements, fees, course content, assessment methods, teaching arrangements, and the qualification they will receive. They should also be told which organisation awards the qualification and what recognition or approval applies to the particular programme.

Where recognition is limited, conditional, or dependent on further assessment, those limitations should be explained plainly.

This is particularly important when institutions use terms such as “internationally accredited,” “recognised,” or “approved.” These descriptions should lead to verifiable information, not leave students to interpret a logo.

The appropriate question is not simply whether an institution holds an accreditation certificate. It is who issued it, what was reviewed, which programmes or activities it covers, and what it means for the student’s intended next step.

Independent external review should never be presented as an automatic substitute for the approvals or recognition required by the relevant national authorities or professional bodies.

Transparency may appear less impressive than a bold marketing claim. It is nevertheless a stronger foundation for trust.

Judge quality through the learning experience

A quality framework should be felt in classrooms, learning platforms, assessment practices, and student support services.

Do lecturers provide useful feedback? Are assessments designed to test understanding rather than memorisation alone? Can students obtain academic guidance when they struggle? Is there a fair and accessible process for raising concerns?

Institutions should be willing to ask these questions even when the answers are uncomfortable.

Student feedback should be more than a questionnaire collected at the end of a course. It should help inform decisions about teaching, resources, and support. Equally, students should be told what changed because they spoke up.

A practical starting point would be for institutions to publish a short annual account of the concerns students raised and the improvements made in response. Such an account need not disclose confidential information or create an elaborate reporting burden. Its purpose would be to demonstrate that listening leads to action.

Make flexible learning accountable

The debate about educational quality should also avoid treating flexibility and rigour as opposing goals.

An online or blended programme should be judged by the clarity of its learning outcomes, the quality of teaching, the integrity of assessment, and the support available to learners—not by its delivery format alone.

The Maldives Qualifications Authority’s audit guidelines make a related point: the relevant standards and qualification-framework requirements should be met regardless of a programme’s mode of delivery.

For institutions, this should mean asking practical questions before expanding flexible provision. Can students access learning materials reliably? Are teaching staff prepared to support remote learners? Are assessment expectations clear? What happens when a student falls behind?

Flexibility should widen opportunity without transferring the entire burden of learning to the student.

Treat external review as a starting point

The greatest value of external review should be what happens after the review is completed.

An institution might receive recommendations to strengthen its governance, update its curriculum, improve assessment, or provide better student support. Those recommendations become meaningful only when someone takes responsibility for implementing them.

For organisations such as the International Association for Quality Assurance in Pre-Tertiary & Higher Education (QAHE), the principle should be equally clear: the value of accreditation ought to be measured not by the visibility of a certificate, but by the improvements it encourages institutions to make.

Every improvement plan should therefore answer three straightforward questions: What will change? Who is responsible? How will progress be assessed?

Institutional leaders should also resist the temptation to treat a successful review as the end of the process. A certificate records an assessment; it cannot, by itself, ensure that the same standards will be sustained.

Quality requires continuing attention, including when no external visit is approaching.

Put the learner first

The most persuasive account of educational quality is not a collection of logos. It is an institution that explains its commitments clearly, teaches responsibly, responds to concerns, and can demonstrate how it is improving.

Students should not have to become accreditation specialists to make an informed educational choice. Institutions and quality assurance organisations should make the relevant distinctions easier to understand.

For the Maldives, a constructive way forward is to keep the learner at the centre of the discussion. Every policy, partnership, review, and institutional claim should ultimately face the same test: does it help students receive an education worthy of their time, effort, and trust?

That is a more demanding standard than possessing a certificate. It is also the standard that matters most.

This is an Opinion Editorial penned by Prof. Stéphane Narcis, the Honorary President and Honorary QA Auditor at QAHE.

He holds a PhD in Film Studies, a DLitt, and a PDLitt, with further degrees from King’s College London and the University of Winchester. His work spans film and cultural studies, intercultural communication, and quality assurance in education.

Topics

Discuss

Sign Using

350 characters remaining